Best Winter Carp Boilies 2025: A Total Fishing Tackle Review

Winter carp fishing can be a tough prospect. The fish are harder to catch for sure. But there are things you can do to swing the scales in your favour and give yourself the best chance of a winter bite! One of those things is to choose the right carp bait, and a good winter boilie is great for pre-baiting and for chucking out into the pond in pursuit of those winter carp.

But which ones should you choose?

THE BEST WINTER BOILIES!

Now, there are a lot of choices when it comes to choosing the the best carp fishing boilies, and half of them can be discounted straight away as they are designed for use in warmer water temperatures. From what is left, there is a good choice for winter carp fishing, but there are some that perform better than others year in and year out.

Mainline Cell takes some beating, and despite being around now for a good number of years, the Cell still catches an insane amount of carp and will work anywhere!

Much Baits Creamseed is massively underrated. Catching consistently in cold weather is a true test of a winter boilie, and the Creamseed passes with flying colours.

Sticky Baits Manilla - with or without the Active coating, the Manilla is a winter winner! Consistently catching stacks of carp every year in the cold months.

Shop Now

Mainline Essential Cell Shelf Life

Sticky Baits Manilla Active

DNA Baits The Bug

Mainline Essential Cell - The Essential Cell™ builds on the unrivaled success that is synonymous with the original Cell™ and the renowned Essential IB. The result is a bait that will work the moment it enters the water, regardless of temperature. A full range of Essential Cell™ Pop-Ups, Wafters, Groundbait, Additives, Pellets and Particles are also available to complete your armoury.  Three decades of cutting-edge experience and our extensive research and development process have enabled us to formulate this bait, especially for the UK and European carp angler; a complete food-source boilie that you can use with total confidence because it’s a Mainline bait… Better bait through research.

Sticky Baits Manilla Active -  born from the formulation of our original Active boilie, the Manilla Active incorporates the same state-of-the-art process as our Krill Active. Each bait still contains the perfect levels of milk and bird food proteins, as well as the divine Madagascan vanilla extract and peanut protein that Manilla is famous for. In addition to this, the boilies have undergone a unique coating process, which encapsulates them in a rich paste layer. Upon contact with the water, the coating around the outside of Manilla Active begins to break down. This releases a tantalising wave of attraction thanks to the super-soluble blend of powders and liquids used in its makeup. Free amino acids flood out from your baited area, which helps draw carp into your swim and keep them there for longer.

DNA Baits The Bug - Regarding the flavour profile of the bait, the most common comment from anybody lucky enough to test it is: “Ooh… that doesn’t smell like I thought it would!” Understandable, I guess, for a bait primarily based around an insect meal, but we have smoothed the aroma of the bait out both with a creamy, powdered taste enhancer, along with a unique and proven flavour blend we have successfully used for years. This combination gives the bait an almost creamy, chocolate malt-type of aroma. If you’re brave enough to taste it, you’ll be greeted with a lovely nutty, creamy flavour that certainly isn’t expected.

We asked around the anglers at Berners Hall Fishery in Essex, which would they choose and the results were quite even! There was a winner though and that was Sticky Baits Manilla Active!

Shop Now